Paint & Painters Supplies in Cleveland, OH

Paint can with red paint drips and a brush resting across the top
Blue paint tray with roller covers, paintbrush, and tools on a white surface

Authorized Benjamin Moore Dealer — Expert Paint Selection

Sutton Industrial Hardware is a proud authorized dealer of Benjamin Moore paint — one of the most respected names in premium interior and exterior coatings. Whether you're refreshing a single room, repainting an entire home exterior, or tackling a commercial property project, our experienced staff will help you choose the right product, sheen, and color combination to achieve the results you're after.


Unlike the big-box stores where you're on your own in the paint aisle, our team has decades of experience with Benjamin Moore's product line and can walk you through every option honestly. We match colors, discuss prep requirements, and make recommendations based on your specific surface conditions and project goals.


Benjamin Moore Products


Interior Paints

Benjamin Moore's interior paint line covers everything from entry-level value products to premium zero-VOC formulations ideal for bedrooms, nurseries, and high-traffic living areas. We carry a full range of sheens — flat, matte, eggshell, satin, semi-gloss, and gloss — and can color-match to any Benjamin Moore swatch or bring in custom colors. Ask our staff about Aura, Regal Select, and Ben interior collections. A division of Benjamin Moore makes a lead blocker paint that we stock.

Exterior Paints

Cleveland's weather demands a quality exterior paint. Our exterior Benjamin Moore line is designed to hold up against freeze-thaw cycles, summer UV, and the moisture exposure common in Northeast Ohio. We carry products appropriate for wood, masonry, aluminum, and composite siding surfaces, along with the primers and prep products needed to ensure adhesion and longevity.


Rust-Oleum Products

We carry a comprehensive line of Rust-Oleum coatings, primers, and specialty finishes. Rust-Oleum is a go-to brand for metal, concrete, and industrial applications — offering rust-preventive primers, oil-based coatings, spray paints in dozens of colors, and specialty products for specific surfaces and conditions. Ideal for contractors, facilities managers, and serious DIYers working on metal, concrete, wood, and more.


Deck Stains

Protect and restore your outdoor deck with the right stain product. We carry both semi-transparent and solid deck stains in a range of colors — appropriate for pressure-treated, cedar, and weathered wood decks. Our staff can assess your deck's condition and help you determine whether a semi-transparent or solid stain is the right approach, which prep steps are required, and what product will deliver the best protection for Cleveland's outdoor conditions.


Our store stock high-quality products including B M Woodlux Semi-Transparent stains and Penofin Stain and Sealer. Call or stop by our store and one of our friendly and knowledgeable staff will be happy to assist you.


Paint Supplies & Sundries

A quality paint job depends on quality application tools. We carry Wooster brushes and rollers, Zinsser primers and problem-solving products, painter's tape, plastic sheeting, drop cloths, roller covers, trays, and all the sundries needed to complete a professional paint job from prep to finish coat.

Fan of color swatches with a paintbrush on a light gray background
Paint cans with colored labels lined up on a store shelf in a paint aisle

Who We Serve

Our paint department serves homeowners looking to refresh their spaces, contractors working on residential and commercial repaint projects, property managers maintaining rental or commercial properties, and handymen taking on a variety of interior and exterior painting jobs. We can handle single-can purchases and large project orders alike.

Visit Us at 3848 Prospect Ave., Cleveland, OH